Decisions

Keep up to date on the latest Commercial List decisions.

The decisions below represent all Commercial List matters published on CanLII in the last year. This list will be updated every week. 
Decisions
  • keywords: Procedure — Costs — Supplementary costs endorsement — Whether costs endorsement should be varied to correct missing fees — Separate Bill of Costs for Chernos, Flaherty Svonkin LLP services — No further submissions received — Paragraph of costs endorsement varied — Costs fixed | Procedure — Costs — Rule 57.01 factors — Whether fees claimed on a full indemnity basis are fair and reasonable — Amount claimed for Chernos, Flaherty Svonkin LLP described in Bill of Costs — Court satisfied claimed amount falls within reasonable range — Reduction referenced for substantial indemnity costs — Costs fixed | Procedure — Costs — Counsel fees — Whether costs for legal services provided by Chernos, Flaherty Svonkin LLP should be awarded — Services included legal research, drafting, witness preparation, and attending at trial — Hours for lead counsel, second counsel, and articling student noted — Court satisfied costs should be awarded — Costs fixed

    CanLII | Nov 9, 2026

  • keywords: Procedure — Costs — Offers to settle — Rules of Civil Procedure, r. 57.01 — Whether the offer to settle triggers substantial indemnity costs — Offer proposed resolving claims through arbitration and addressed contemplated injunction jurisdiction — No other factors justifying elevated scale — Partial indemnity costs awarded | Procedure — Costs — Fixing costs — Rules of Civil Procedure, r. 57.01 — Boucher v. Public Accountants Council for the Province of Ontario — Whether costs must reflect what is fair and reasonable for the unsuccessful party to pay — Reasonable expectations in relation to the step considered — Fees reduced from amounts claimed — Costs fixed | Procedure — Costs — Assessment of reasonableness — Partial indemnity scale — Whether hours and fees claimed fall outside reasonable expectations given the motion was not unduly complex — Time for preparation of motion record and cross-examinations scrutinised — Use of three lawyers considered — Claimed fees found excessive — Fees reduced | Procedure — Motions — Stay of action — Arbitration Act; forum non conveniens — What costs should be fixed for two successful stay motions — Motion records, facta, reply records, and cross-examinations considered — Costs fixed on partial indemnity for each motion — Costs payable by Plaintiff within 30 days — Costs fixed and payable within 30 days

    CanLII | Nov 9, 2026

  • keywords: Bankruptcy and insolvency — CCAA proceedings — Approval and reverse vesting order — Whether amended RVO structure is fair and reasonable to stakeholders — Harte Gold factors applied, necessity and economic advantages assessed — Synaptive Medical Inc. v. BDC Capital Inc., “fair and reasonable” test — Court approval granted — Amended ARVO approved | Contracts — Surety bonds and indemnity — Related contracts — Whether surety may assert indemnity against the company if lien claimants obtain judgment to recover from lien bonds — Lien Bonds and Indemnity treated as two separate contracts — No impermissible bifurcation found on the record — Indemnity claims against the company barred — Objection rejected | Statutory interpretation — Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act — Court powers and limits — Whether imposed restriction on indemnity claims falls within s. 11, and whether structure offends, by analogy, s. 32(9) — Indemnity not disclaimed and s. 32(9) not directly applicable — Policy behind s. 32(9) not extended — Discretion exercised to approve structure — Amended ARVO approved | Construction — Construction Act liens — Lien bonds and releases — Whether lien claimants’ ability to access lien bonds is preserved, and whether lien bonds and alleged breach of trust claims under Part II of the Construction Act are carved out of releases — Lien Claims retained solely to obtain judgment for recovery from Lien Bonds — Claims against Lien Bonds carved out of releases — Preservation confirmed — Amended ARVO approved

    CanLII | Nov 5, 2026

  • keywords: Bankruptcy and insolvency — Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act — Approval and reverse vesting order — CCAA, s. 11 and s. 36(3) — Reverse vesting order structure and credit bid considered — Stakeholder prejudice and “worse off” concerns raised by lien issues — Court declines to grant proposed ARVO in current form — Stay Period extended | Bankruptcy and insolvency — CCAA sale approval — Reverse vesting order scrutiny — Harte Gold Corp. (Re), Royal Bank of Canada v. Soundair Corp. — Whether ARVO is fair and reasonable and produces a net benefit to the estate — Whether any stakeholder is worse off than under a bankruptcy — Additional scrutiny for RVO not satisfied on the record — Relief refused | Construction — Construction liens and security — Lien bonds — Construction Act, s. 44 — Whether ARVO wording could prejudice Lien Bonds or lien claimants’ rights — Proposed deeming of ResidualCo as substitute for the Company under Lien Bonds contested by surety — Uncertainty as to effect of transferring Excluded Contracts in an RVO — ARVO not granted in current form | Construction — Statutory trust and holdback — Releases — Construction Act, s. 8 — Whether releases would extinguish potential trust and knowing-receipt claims for monies held back from construction advances — Scope of paragraph 27 releases challenged as potentially prejudicing lien claimants — Court not prepared to dismiss trust argument on the record — ARVO not granted in current form | Bankruptcy and insolvency — Disclaimer of contracts — Pre-sale contracts — Whether court should authorize the Monitor to terminate and disclaim remaining Pre-Sale Contracts as a condition of closing — Pre-Sale Purchasers non-opposition based on sequencing to preserve deposit insurance claims — Provision treated as uncontroversial within proposed ARVO — Relief not granted with ARVO refused in current form

    CanLII | Oct 30, 2026

  • keywords: Contracts — Settlement agreement — Enforcement application — Specific performance and consequential relief sought — Mutual releases held in escrow pending full performance and compliance — Refinance and buyout mechanisms with adjustments and KPMG LLP audit — Disputed performance of discharge and release steps — Application dismissed | Contracts — Repudiation — Settlement agreement — Whether the Applicant breached and repudiated the Settlement Agreement — Objective test for repudiation applied, Remedy Drug Store Co. Inc. v. Farnham and Guarantee Co. of North America v. Gordon Capital Corp. — Innocent party entitled to elect to treat agreement at an end, Olivieri v. Sherman — Application dismissed | Contracts — Specific performance — Releases — Whether specific performance should enforce the Settlement Agreement and mutual releases — Request to discontinue the separate action through enforcement of releases — Directions sought for KPMG LLP audit and calculation of the Equalization Amount — Consequential directions and charge requested — Specific performance refused — Application dismissed | Contracts — Performance — Tender — Whether the Respondent was ready, willing and able to complete the Settlement Agreement — Financing evidence accepted, including draft refinancing documents — Tender not required where repudiation clear, The Rosseau Group Inc. v. 2528061 Ontario Inc. — Closing could not proceed without required discharge statements and discharges — Application dismissed

    CanLII | Oct 29, 2026

  • keywords: Procedure — Class proceedings — Settlement approval — Class Proceedings Act, 1992, s. 29(2) — Whether the Settlement Agreement is fair, reasonable, and in the best interests of the class — Arm’s-length negotiations with mediator and pre-trial judge — No objections to settlement received by hearing date — Settlement approval granted | Procedure — Class proceedings — Class counsel fees — Class Proceedings Act, 1992, s. 32(2) — Whether contingent fees and disbursements are fair and reasonable — Retainer agreements providing 27.5% of gross recovery — Risk undertaken and disbursements funded by counsel — Fees and disbursements approved | Procedure — Class proceedings — Representative plaintiff honorarium — Whether honorarium is justified for time and effort — Assistance with information to class members, discovery, and undertakings — Modest payment in recognition of valuable services — In line with similar amounts in Ontario class actions — Honorarium approved | Procedure — Class proceedings — Distribution plan — Whether distribution protocol and administrative appointments are fair and efficient — Appointment of accountant and claims administrator — Pro rata distribution based on valid claims, minimizing administration costs and unclaimed funds — Transparent and user-friendly claims process — Distribution plan approved

    CanLII | Oct 26, 2026

  • keywords: Contracts — Royalty Agreement — Standing — Assignment — Whether respondents have standing as “Recipients” or assignees — Interpretation of “Recipients” and assignment provisions, including ss. 1.1(gg), 3.5.1 and 8.1.1 — Whether assignment of less than 100% is effective as against Payor — Standing affirmed | Limitation periods — Limitations Act, 2002 — Laches — Whether s. 5 bars assertion of contingent NSR on unproduced claims — “Claim” defined as remedy for injury, loss or damage from act or omission — No obligation to register, nothing due and payable — Limitations and laches rejected | Contracts — Interpretation — “Area of interest” — Royalty Agreement, s. 9.13.1 — Whether “Property” expands to claims contiguous to or within 1.5 km — Whether clause creates a dynamic, iterative perimeter “as may be expanded from time to time” — Plain meaning applied, static definition modified — Expansion interpretation confirmed | Property — Land titles — Notices on title — Land Titles Act, s. 160 — Whether court should order registered NSR notices removed and title “cleansed” — Notices described as contingent, for notice purposes — No basis found to remove registrations given interpretation of Royalty Agreement — Application dismissed with costs payable on partial indemnity scale

    CanLII | Oct 23, 2026

  • keywords: Procedure — Arbitration — Costs — Arbitration Act, 1991 — Whether court could reverse arbitrator’s costs award where not pleaded — Notice of Application contained no relief or grounds on that issue — Possible avenues under ss. 15(3) and 46 noted but not pursued — No findings on propriety of arbitrator’s costs award — Relief refused | Procedure — Arbitration — Costs of application — Arbitration Act, 1991, ss. 13(6), 15 — Applicant sought costs of successful application removing arbitrator — Costs follow the event presumptively — Respondent supported arbitrator’s position and failed on merits — Partial indemnity costs fixed as fair and reasonable — Costs ordered | Procedure — Costs — Principles — Whether costs should be ordered absent wrongdoing by Respondent — Costs do not generally turn on express wrongdoing — Successful party presumptively kept whole — Costs provide settlement incentive despite belief of no wrongdoing — Respondent responsible for portion of Applicant’s costs — Costs ordered

    CanLII | Oct 22, 2026

  • keywords: Procedure — Applications — Conversion to action — Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 38.10(1)(b) — Whether application to enforce Guarantee should proceed to trial — Application not appropriate where issues go beyond interpretation of document — Case conference to set pleadings and discovery plan — Application converted to action | Evidence — Credibility — Need for viva voce evidence — Whether material factual disputes and credibility assessments prevent determination on a paper record — Cross-examinations on affidavits and undertakings insufficient for disputes — Non-party evidence and documentary production required — Trial required for proper determination — Application converted to action | Contracts — Guarantees — Waiver and entire agreement clauses — Whether waiver of defences and non-reliance clauses necessarily bar defences based on bad-faith performance, misrepresentation, and promissory estoppel — Duty of good faith in contractual performance cannot be contracted out of — Defences not automatically extinguished — Conversion granted | Procedure — Costs — Costs in the cause — Whether to make any costs award on the conversion motion — Successful moving parties but motion record largely factual and usable for discoveries and continued pursuit of the action — Court not inclined to make any award as to costs — Costs payable in the cause

    CanLII | Oct 20, 2026

  • keywords: Bankruptcy and insolvency — CCAA proceedings — Sale and investment solicitation process — Whether SISP should be run with CRO as ultimate decision-maker — Authority to waive bidding criteria, select successful bid, finalize transaction — Fairness, transparency and integrity of court-ordered process — Secured Lenders’ Proposed SISP approved, Debtors’ motion dismissed | Bankruptcy and insolvency — DIP financing — Consent rights and reasonable discretion — Whether DIP Lender could refuse Debtors’ Proposed SISP under s. 27 of DIP Facility — SISP terms required to be acceptable to DIP Lender in reasonable discretion — Support from Monitor and secured creditors considered — Debtors’ Proposed SISP rejected | Bankruptcy and insolvency — Court powers — CCAA, s. 11 jurisdiction — Whether court may order SISP giving CRO ultimate decision-making authority — Distinction from removal of directors and s. 11.5 — Debtor-in-possession governance maintained for operations while CRO runs sale process — Jurisdiction confirmed, CRO empowered under SISP

    CanLII | Oct 14, 2026

Show more (1175)